I refer to a classic piece of spin doctoring on the recent Global Witness exposé by a blogger calling himself/herself The Benchmark entitled “Global Witness on Taib: Was it really a sting operation?” Click on http://thebenchmark0.blogspot.com/2013/03/global-witness-on-taib-was-it-really.html to read this rather lame attempt at shifting the blame.
The piece by The Benchmark desperately tries to deflect, distract and ‘turn the tables’ on Global Witness, which is why I call it a classic text-book case
of Spin-Doctoring 101. In a nutshell, the writer is saying that the exposé is
“a well crafted conspiracy against Taib by his own kin,” and supports his/her
conspiracy theories by resurrecting the old and tired story of the Tun Rahman
Yakub versus Taib Mahmud ‘feud’ of the 80s. Whether or not the ‘feud’ was real
or simply a ‘sandiwara’ (shadow play) is beside the point. It was a very public
spat, and Taib made a big show of withdrawing licences issued by his uncle to
drive home the point that the fight was indeed genuine.
Then, after Taib had allegedly identified and neutered his
enemies (per kindness of the dramas that unfolded at a certain Ming Court Hotel in Kuala Lumpur many years ago), consolidated his position and
solidified his political strength, this happened:
A heart-warming and tearful reunion of uncle and nephew was
carefully choreographed and publicised, and the dynasty was intact. Nevertheless, in a very recent video interview by Taib, he retorts, “Are you trying to frame me?” suggesting that hidden hands are now at work to undermine him. Classic Taib!
Before we fall into this trap
of being distracted by the conspiracy theories being espoused by The Benchmark,
let us first examine the facts before us, and deconstruct the arguments
advocated by The Benchmark one by one.
Conspiracy Theory No. 1 put forward by The Benchmark is that
the sisters Fatimah and Norlia are allegedly conspiring, with the help of
Global Witness, against Taib. This proposal sounds eerily familiar and seems to
be following the lead given by Taib in that same recent video interview. In Hollywood, this would most likely be the
plot a screen-writer would weave. But in real life Sarawak (and sisters Norlia
and Fatimah are no Oscar award winning actresses, mind you), this plot would
be stretching fantasy to its limit.
Both sisters clearly said in the video exposé
that their RM2 ringgit company, Ample Agro, owns the Provisional Licence to the
piece of land in Julau which they were hoping to sell to the investor at
RM4,000 per acre. Now if the relationship between Taib and the Tun Rahman side
of the family is still indeed strained, then it begs one very important and
crucial question – WHO issued the licence to Ample Agro in 2011 for a mere
RM12,500 annual rent? See Exhibit A
below, which is a print screen from the video:
Sure, there are procedures and committees in place to ensure
provisional licences are issued according to government process, but certainly
it would be incredible to suggest that the Chief Minister was completely
unaware of this one licence, especially if it was being applied for by a side of
his family that was supposedly having a strained relationship with him. Taib
suggested in his video interview that the sisters were trying to be
intermediaries and trying to push their familial connection with Taib as bait. My
point is simple – the sisters’ company already owned the licence! They were not
fishing. They had already caught the fish! What they were trying to do in the
video was sell the fish! So who gave them the fish in the first place, and how
much was it sold for? Peanuts? Groundnuts? Cashew nuts? Pistachio nuts? And how much were they offering Ample Agro
for? RM4,000 per acre, which works out to a cool profit of USD$16 million (RM50
million). See Exhibit B below, which is a print screen from the video:
The next argument put forward by The Benchmark is that there
is a sinister plot to derail Taib’s succession plan, and The Benchmark backs
this Conspiracy Theory No. 2 with news that the Court of Appeal had recently dismissed
Norlia’s other company’s case, also about….a provisional licence! This apparent lost by Norlia is subtly
suggested as the reason behind her taking revenge. But….the Court of Appeal’s
decision was only reported on the 6th of March this year! Just a
week before the Global Witness story hit the news!
Could Global Witness, the
sisters and their lawyers, and the RECODA Officer who pointed Global Witness in
the direction of the sisters have orchestrated this whole earth-shattering
reveal and worked furiously to come up with a polished and water-tight exposé in
just under a week, motivated by revenge? Basically, The Benchmark writer is
trying to deflect our attention by implying that the sisters are plotting
(together with Daddy and other prominent sisters?) to oust cousin Taib, and
this is supported by the timing of the Court of Appeal decision. Does this theory hold water?
Let us look at the facts – Global Witness had obviously shot
this film months back, and I arrive at this conclusion by the simple fact that
Global Witness had put their allegations to all those featured in the video
after shooting was completed, and all of them responded except for the sisters.
Global Witness states this clearly at the end of the video, and Taib himself
was already well aware of the existence of the Global Witness exposé even before
it was aired on Al-Jazeera and appeared online last week. His lawyers in London
have been busy:
Taib, the sisters and the lawyers were all well aware of the
Global Witness exposé probably months back (or at the very least a few weeks
back) even before it hit the news and made the headlines last week because they
were all consulted and asked to answer the allegations. This may have been
explosive news to us last week, but it certainly was not news to Taib, the
lawyers and the sisters. The time frame makes all the difference! So, for this exposé
to be a well-crafted scheme in the time frame the writer suggests is next to
impossible, not even with the best Hollywood producers and directors involved working 24 hours for a whole week.
Commercial break: Check out the fabulous jewellery.
Now we come to our learnéd friends Messrs. Chong and Huang. Now
why would these lawyers risk their respective reputations and rice bowls just
to frame Taib? The Benchmark may argue that they were mere pawns in a diabolical
chess game and totally unaware that they were lambs led unwittingly to the
slaughter by the sisters. Which could be probable and in which case we pray
that Messrs Chong and Huang initiate the appropriate legal proceedings against
the sisters to clear their names. (But is there such a recourse provided in law?) What if the sisters were really not
acting? Were the lawyers acting then? Highly unlikely, if you study the confidence and demeanor portrayed by both lawyers.
The final and pivotal dynamic that dismantles and demolishes
The Benchmark’s two conspiracy theories is the fact that YB Datuk Norah Abdul
Rahman, currently the Member of Parliament for Tanjong Manis and sister to both Fatimah and Norlia, AND part owner of Ample Agro
as alleged in the video, has far too much to lose from this whole debacle. The
timing of the exposé could not have come at a worse time for her – GE13 is but
around the corner. Why rock the boat now? Why bite the hands that feed you?
Exhibit C - Happy Family:
Exhibit C - Happy Family:
To recapitulate and summarise: Taib is now pointing the
finger back at the sisters and insinuating that a Machiavellian scheme is being
forged to discredit him, while horribly forgetting that the licence had already
been given to the company owned by the sisters in 2011. Is he spin-doctoring
and trying to throw us off the scent? Will the licence be revoked and withdrawn
from Ample Agro? What will become of Norah, Sisters & Co? Most despicable
of all, is he now throwing them to the dogs in order to save his own skin and
crying Ming Court II to get us all frenzied and fired up and chasing shadows instead?
The final nail in the coffin of the credibility of The
Benchmark is the obviously wrong information on Justin Jinggut promoting
himself as PKR Supremo in Sarawak. Seriously? The writer should really research
his/her story before putting foot in mouth.
Let us be clear. The two real issues flagged by the Global
Witness exposé are (i) land-grab and (ii) tax evasion, and no matter how much the
spin-doctors try to spin, the damage has been done. The crux of the whole
fiasco is that the indigenous peoples of Sarawak are now regarded by Norlia
(and dare we assume the entire clan?) as simply squatters on their own lands
and those who have disenfranchised them evade tax on the transaction of these
lands on a massive scale.
The man whom the public is looking to for real answers now and not just flimsy regurgitated rhetoric is the Chief Minister of Sarawak. Will he man up and give us the answers or will he shift the blame, as what The Benchmark is trying desperately to do on his behalf? SQUATTER-GATE will be Taib's undoing, and he knows it too well, and that is why the next few days and weeks will be crucial - the peoples, mostly SQUATTERS (by definition of Datin Norlia Tun Abdul Rahman Yakub), of Sarawak are angry and even the Barisan Nasional supporters who are also SQUATTERS by definition are quietly angry.
Shahrizat has her cows, now Taib has his squatters. SQUATTER-GATE is the silver bullet that Sarawak has been waiting for to finish off the werewolves. Shoot accurately and aim for the heart.
(Or if you watch The Walking Dead, aim for the brain.)
33 comments:
Taib's spin doctors have said a number of contradictory things to try and get him off the hook in squatter gate - they have said his own family "framed him", meaning that all the fat hangers on who have benefitted from millions of ringgit of concessions suddenly decided to bite the hand that feeds them. At the same time others have implied that the cousins who called the native people "squatters" are not in fact real cousins of Taib after all. Which is it to be? Is Taib accusing his family of disloyalty or is he saying they were also "framed"?
Taib has at the same time blamed a completely different supposed conspirator against him, saying that Anwar Ibrahim has worked with Global Witness to "frame" him in this film. So Taib, are you saying that Uncle Abdul Rahman sat down with Anwar Ibrahim and the environmental chaps from Global Witness and concocted this complicated story together to "frame" him?
Working with them would also have had to have been one of his own top lawyers Alvin Chong, who represents the Land and Survey Department. Chong substantiated all the cousins said and more, so why would he want to "frame" the hand that feeds him? And of course included in the plot would also have to be the Hii family, a top business crony who relies on Taib for all his fat concessions. The Hii family representative admitted Taib expects kickbacks and confirmed his reputation as Mr 10% (over and over to make nearer 60% on each deal).
Were all these different people, both political opponents and NGOs and cronies and cousins and lawyers working together to "frame" Taib?
Isn't it more simple and believable to accept the truth, which is that his fat silly cousins, his lawyer and his business crony were indiscreet towards a person they thought they were doing a corrupt business deal with and they all spilled the beans? After all, the whole of Sarawak knows this is how lands are sold and taxes avoided and everyone knows the Chief Minister is behind it.
Its pre-plan. But even then the facts the Rahman girls mentioned Dayaks are squatters does not gone well. Too obvious that dayaks are being degraded to its lowest level.
This is excellent Vernon Kedit my dearest Cousin. I am so very very proud of you and this piece. Brilliant!! xoxoxox
Bronwyn Ward, the word 'cousin' is now off limit. Lol. Vernon, I salute this article. Yes, Benchmark was being typical spin doctor. To suggest that an accomplished lawyer would incriminate himself with tax evasion in order to frame someone else would not even meet the logic level of an amoeba!
The earlier sufferance buying hallmark Burberry issued profit admonition,[url=http://www.jppradaoutlet2013.com/#234540][b]プラダ 店舗[/b][/url]
, the keep apprehensive about the prospects representing magnificence goods. PRADA (Prada, Hong Kong stocks 01,913),[url=http://www.jppradaoutlet2013.com/#234558][b]PRADA 財布[/b][/url]
how in the world, has announced the interim results, no incredulity allowing in the service of with respect to the for the most part superstore into a tonic. PRADA portrayal in the beginning half of this year, the age in which to communicate out a reticulum profit of 286 million euros, [url=http://www.jppradaoutlet2013.com/#234553][b]プラダ ポーチ[/b][/url]
,representing a well-spoken year-on-year nurturing of 59.5%, sales of goods of several kinds in,[url=http://www.jppradaoutlet2013.com/#234547][b]プラダ 店舗[/b][/url]
,a number of regions of the domain be long-lasting improved dramatically, with uncommonly balanced crop in the Asia-Pacific dominion has ripen into the comrades's fastest-growing compass, [url=http://www.jppradaoutlet2013.com/#234535][b]プラダ トート デニム[/b][/url]
,galling sales increased 44.7%. Analysts said that with of a higher order purchasing power of Chinese consumers is self-possession the unadulterated dominant shore up the crop of the extensive luxury goods.
PRADA interim be of consequence betray powerful advance, but in act,[url=http://www.jppradaoutlet2013.com/#234555][b]リュック プラダ[/b][/url]
,http://www.jppradaoutlet2013.com from mid-August, a adjustment in conduct therapy brand. Media producer specializes in manufacturing compared with the low-priced products are being attacked at near the protuberance of the fruitful downturn, but growth is stationary indifferent to extricate the exorbitant freeway of brand name Hermes form month raised its 2012 sales nurturing goal to 12%.
The Paleo Diet Listlithic diet is a modern fad, and they did not feel as hungry.
Make yourself accountable When shopping to restock the kitchen
be sure to rinse them before eating to get rid of acne
and other ailments.
Review my page :: loren cordain age
Be sure you have all that compiled, you have to work hard to
run a pagerank successfully needs planning till the last detail.
S Pagerank when we owned that and now we're completing that exercise in Europe for finance. This guidance reflects an anticipated decline in gross margins with expected net pricing per case growth for '13.
My homepage ... los angeles seo
They have the amounts that they bid on various sealed bid contracts.
Evaluating affordability of company:- Large number of companies
offer affordable traffic packages for benefit of their clients.
In the example above, a Google search on these sites and bookmark them for your use.
Do not forget the keywords in the Meta description. These are scammers who fool unknowing customers to
pay for is also highly dubious.
Look at my webpage :: seo copywriting
This excellent website definitely has all the information and facts I wanted about
this subject and didn't know who to ask.
Check out my homepage - ジョーダン
Great web site you've got here.. It's hard to find high quality writing like yours these days.
I honestly appreciate people like you! Take care!!
Feel free to visit my blog post オークリー
It's an awesome article in support of all the web viewers; they will obtain benefit from it I am sure.
my web-site: アバクロンビーフィッチレディース
What's Taking place i am new to this, I stumbled upon this I have found It positively useful and it has helped me out loads. I hope to contribute & assist other customers like its helped me. Good job.
My site ... プラダ トートバッグ
Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all people you really recognize what you're talking about! Bookmarked. Please additionally seek advice from my website =). We could have a hyperlink trade arrangement among us
my site - モンスターケーブル
We stumbled over here from a different web page and thought I should check things out.
I like what I see so now i'm following you. Look forward to looking over your web page yet again.
My web blog :: エアジョーダン
What's up to every one, the contents existing at this website are in fact amazing for people knowledge, well, keep up the nice work fellows.
My blog ... プラダ
Hi, I do believe this is a great blog. I stumbledupon it ;)
I'm going to return once again since I saved as a favorite it. Money and freedom is the greatest way to change, may you be rich and continue to guide others.
Also visit my web page - レイバンサングラス
Wow! At last I got a website from where I be capable of in fact take useful information concerning my study and knowledge.
Take a look at my web page: レイバンサングラス
After looking at a few of the blog posts on your blog, I seriously appreciate your way of writing a blog.
I book-marked it to my bookmark webpage list and will be checking back in the near
future. Please check out my website as well and let me know your opinion.
My web blog ... レイバン
It's really very complex in this full of activity life to listen news on TV, therefore I only use internet for that purpose, and take the most up-to-date information.
Also visit my webpage ... プラダバッグ
Great article! This is the kind of information that are meant to be shared across the web.
Shame on Google for no longer positioning this submit higher!
Come on over and discuss with my site . Thanks =)
my site ロレックスレプリカ
Remarkable issues here. I am very happy to see your article.
Thank you so much and I am taking a look forward to contact
you. Will you kindly drop me a mail?
My site; シャネル アウトレット
Greetings! I know this is kind of off topic but I
was wondering if you knew where I could get a captcha plugin for
my comment form? I'm using the same blog platform as yours and I'm having problems finding one?
Thanks a lot!
My site - プラダ
I've learn some excellent stuff here. Certainly worth bookmarking for revisiting. I surprise how much attempt you set to make any such excellent informative website.
Stop by my blog: オークリー サングラス
I'm not sure exactly why but this weblog is loading extremely slow for me. Is anyone else having this issue or is it a problem on my end? I'll check back later on and see
if the problem still exists.
Here is my page - monster ヘッドホン
Good day! I could have sworn I've visited this blog before but after going through many of the posts I realized it's new to me.
Anyhow, I'm certainly happy I discovered it and I'll be bookmarking it and checking back frequently!
Here is my site エアジョーダン
I was able to find good info from your articles.
Also visit my web blog ... モンスタービート
And their reading and attention skills were compared before and after they played action
or non-action video game shelves for nine 80-minute sessions.
Here is my web-site ... Fun Video Games
I think the admin of this web page is genuinely working hard for his web page, as here every stuff is quality based material.
My website - reset password
helpful resources is generic propecia just as good - generic propecia thailand
I read this paragraph fully about the difference of
most recent and previous technologies, it's awesome article.
my weblog ... top 10 products
It's amazing to pay a quick visit this site and reading the views of all colleagues regarding this article, while I am also eager of getting knowledge.
My blog; only the best review
Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It in fact used to
be a enjoyment account it. Glance complex to far brought agreeable from you!
By the way, how could we keep up a correspondence?
Feel free to surf to my webpage video reviews
page human hair wigs,hair extensions,cheap wigs,wigs for women,cheap wigs human hair,human hair toppers,hair pieces for women,costume wigs,cheap wigs human hair browse around these guys
Post a Comment